Feedback? Ideas? Complaints? Suggestions? Request for report about other area? send me a message!
This page was generated using data obtained on 2024-03-31. Please, send me a message if you want it updated!




Remember to check whether edits make sense! All reports are on this page because these tasks require human judgment to verify whether the proposed edit makes sense. Some proposed edits will be wrong, in such case they should be not done and problem reported


Wikipedia article linked from OSM object using wikipedia tag is missing.
Often article was moved without leaving redirect and wikipedia tag should be edited to point to the new one.
Article may be deleted and no longer existing, or link was never valid. In such cases wikipedia tag should be deleted.

Wallburg Engelskirchen - an affected OSM element that may be improved

overpass query usable in JOSM that will load all objects where this specific error is present:
[out:xml][timeout:3600]; ( relation(6858088)['wikipedia'='de:Wallburg Engelskirchen']; ); (._;>;); out meta qt;//['wikipedia tag links to 404']


should use a secondary wikipedia tag - linking from wikipedia and wikidata tag to a transport accident
linked wikidata entry (Q882204)(Eisenbahnunfall von Radevormwald article) is about a transport accident, so it is very unlikely to be correct
subject:wikipedia=* tag would be probably better (see https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:wikipedia#Secondary_Wikipedia_links for full list of what else may be applicable)
in case of change remember to remove wikidata tag if it is present
object categorised by Wikidata - wrong classification may be caused by wrong data on Wikidata
an affected OSM element that may be improved

overpass query usable in JOSM that will load all objects where this specific error is present:
[out:xml][timeout:3600]; ( node(10866802935)['wikidata'='Q882204']; ); (._;>;); out meta qt;//['should use a secondary wikipedia tag - linking from wikipedia and wikidata tag to a transport accident']


wikipedia wikidata mismatch
wikidata and wikipedia tags link to a different objects (Q1498760 vs Q1368200 wikidata id assigned to linked Wikipedia article)
Espert - an affected OSM element that may be improved

wikidata and wikipedia tags link to a different objects (Q1368200 vs Q1498760 wikidata id assigned to linked Wikipedia article)
Geilensiepen - an affected OSM element that may be improved

overpass query usable in JOSM that will load all objects where this specific error is present:
[out:xml][timeout:3600]; ( node(7295005165)['wikidata'='Q1498760']['wikipedia'='de:Espert']; node(7295007194)['wikidata'='Q1368200']['wikipedia'='de:Geilensiepen']; ); (._;>;); out meta qt;//['wikipedia wikidata mismatch']


wikipedia wikidata mismatch - wikipedia points to disambiguation page and wikidata does not
wikidata and wikipedia tags link to a different objects, because wikidata tag points to a redirect that should be followed
article claims to point to disambig, wikidata does not. wikidata tag is likely to be correct, wikipedia tag almost certainly is not
Birkenbach - an affected OSM element that may be improved
de:Birkenbach -> de:Birkenbach (Nümbrecht)
Birkenbach (Nümbrecht)

overpass query usable in JOSM that will load all objects where this specific error is present:
[out:xml][timeout:3600]; ( node(2021476552)['wikidata'='Q865518']['wikipedia'='de:Birkenbach']; ); (._;>;); out meta qt;//['wikipedia wikidata mismatch - wikipedia points to disambiguation page and wikidata does not']

Other useful resources

JOSM Wikipedia plugin


Note to self: online version hosted at https://matkoniecz.github.io/OSM-wikipedia-tag-validator-reports, files are stored at https://github.com/matkoniecz/OSM-wikipedia-tag-validator-reports.